From the Rav’s Desk – Q&A’s on Tefilas Haderech and more

On the road versus within the city:[1] Tefilas Haderech is to be recited after leaving the city and its outskirts, which is defined as the area within 70 Amos from the city. One is not to say it while still within the city or its outskirts even if he has already began his travel. If one recited it while still in the city, after having decided to travel and preparing to leave, then he fulfills his obligation and is not to repeat it once he leaves the city that day. [If, however, he did not leave that day, or had not yet prepared himself to leave when he recited the prayer, then he must repeat the prayer upon traveling.]

[1] Admur 110:6

Is it true that the Rebbe Rashab was clinically depressed?

It is recorded that when the Rebbe Rashab was in his early 40s he went through a period of “Nemichus Haruach” which is literally translated as a low spirit [i.e. sadness]. [Interestingly, this is the typical age that an individual goes through a midlife crisis which is often seen as a period of self-reflection, questioning, and emotional turmoil that can come in middle adulthood.] This does not however connote depression or clinical depression, for which the word in Hebrew is Atzvus. Now, while it is possible to argue based on the context of the story that there was some stage or level of depression present, there is no proof that this is the case, and that the Rebbe Rashab actually suffered from this medical condition. Accordingly, I would dismiss this diagnosis of the Rebbe Rashab as rumor and gossip at worst, and as speculation at best. One thing is for certain that this entire episode lasted within a single year, and therefore to state that the Rebbe Rashab suffered from clinical depression which can be interpreted as a lifetime battle, is simply inaccurate.

 

See Reshimos Hyaoman p. 229; Toras Menachem 33:431; Admurei Chabad Veyahadus Austria p. 78

From the Rav’s Desk: Latest articles and Q&A

Post Views: 129 May one attach two sides of his clothing using a safety pin? May one attach two sides of his clothing using a safety pin?[1] Regarding making it into a double stitch: Some Poskim[2] rule that this should not be done. Others[3] rule that so long as it

Read More »

From the Rav’s Desk: Latest articles, Q&A on spas, bris

Post Views: 167 May one bathe for pleasure purposes during the 12 months of mourning for a parent [i.e. Jacuzzi/spa] Yes. After the conclusion of Shloshim, starting from the morning of the 30th day, the mourner may bathe and shower without restriction, and hence there is no restriction against using

Read More »

From the Rav’s Desk: Q&A on Jacuzzis and churches

Post Views: 148 May one daven or learn Torah in a hotel room that contains a Jacuzzi, such as a couples Zimmer? May one daven or learn Torah in a hotel room that contains a Jacuzzi, such as a couples Zimmer?[1] Yes. It is permitted to study Torah and Daven

Read More »

From the Rav’s Desk: Q&A on RC Kisleiv & More

Post Views: 122 When to celebrate birthday and Bar/Bas Mitzvah if born on the 30th of Kisleiv Question: [Monday 2nd Teves 5782] Today the 30th day of Kisleiv, we Baruch Hashem had a baby boy. I am wondering when this boy will celebrate his birthday in future years when there

Read More »

From the Rav’s Desk – Q&A on after birth care and more

Post Views: 454 Is a husband obligated to provide his wife with cleaning help after birth Is a husband obligated to provide his wife with cleaning help after birth?[1] Some Poskim[2] rule that a husband is obligated to hire a worker to help his wife after she gives birth in

Read More »

About The Author

Leave A Comment?

You must be logged in to post a comment.